veronica_rich: (potc2)
[personal profile] veronica_rich
I was scrolling the hashtags for POTC the other day on Tumblr, looking for some good promo photos or meta from the upcoming fifth movie, when I came across a fairly mild attempt at inciting, about Elizabeth and Will being the most useless characters in the movies. My feelings in order of having them, which might say more about how many years it's been since the fandom wank over the first three movies, were:

1. I wouldn't say "useless," considering their actions drove the storyline right behind Barbossa's

2. There are points where each, in turn, are literally the audience's "viewpoint" character into the world inside the movie; you may not like one or both, but I would say they have usefulness

3. A moderate amount of Jack Sparrow goes a very long way, believe me - if you don't, watch the fourth movie, because as good as Sam Claflin is, Phillip just doesn't have the curbing influence over Jack's character that Will does as straight man (I admit my attitude toward Johnny has changed A LOT in the 14 years since the original hit theaters, and downward, but even then I said Jack is not a character who needs an entire movie about him)

4. Finally I got to hey, quit bashing Will, man

Hopefully if there's a resurgence in the POTC fandom online as a result of this movie - and there might not be, considering all the many franchises out there that have frankly had more consistent and better quality track records - we won't see the level of bashing and hatred that came to infuse it post-DMC. We can do without a repeat of all that.

Date: 2017-05-07 05:03 pm (UTC)
philosophercat: (Default)
From: [personal profile] philosophercat
Wait, a 5th movie?!

Agreed re Jack; part of his charm for me was when he was oblique to the main action going on. We know he's charismatic and fun to watch but he needs to be exploiting the main story of others, if he's gonna shine in a movie-length bit.

Also, hello! :)

Profile

veronica_rich: (Default)
veronica_rich

May 2017

S M T W T F S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324 25 2627
28293031   

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 22nd, 2017 10:53 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios